Skip to main content

A crossed-out price just became a class action. Here is how a New York online store checks its discounts before Black Friday.

A court let a strike-through price suit proceed on October 22, 2026. What New York online stores risk under GBL 349 and 350, and how to fix prices before Black Friday.

Close view of red sale tags hanging from hangers on a metal clothing rack

Your Black Friday sale is built. Every product page shows a crossed-out price next to a lower one, the emails are scheduled, and the shopping feed carries the same numbers. Then a thought lands: when did anyone last sell that jacket at the crossed-out price, and could you prove it if a lawyer asked?

That worry is not paranoia, and the gap is not your fault. Most online store platforms let you type any figure into a "compare at" field, and nothing checks it against your own sales history. On October 22, 2026, a federal judge in California let a class action over one strike-through price on a $39.99 polo go forward, and refused to push it into private arbitration because the store's terms links were too easy to miss. If you run an online store in New York, the same two weak spots sit on your site, and New York adds its own pressure: statutory damages per shopper, a disclosure rule for personalized prices, and an Attorney General who settled an advertised price case one week before that ruling.

This is fixable before Black Friday on November 27. This article covers what the court decided, how New York, California and Texas treat a crossed-out price, where those prices leak into your feeds and emails without anyone checking them, and a short audit that keeps your discounts honest and your conversion rate intact.

$89.50
Struck-through price shown next to a $39.99 polo in the suit a California judge let proceed on October 22, 2026
$500
Minimum damages per injured shopper under New York's false advertising law, up to $10,000 if willful
$1,000
Civil penalty per violation of New York's personalized pricing disclosure rule after a cease and desist letter
$275.1B
US online holiday sales Adobe projects for November and December 2026

What changed: a crossed-out price became a live class action

A federal court refused on October 22, 2026 to throw out or send to arbitration a lawsuit claiming that a retailer's strike-through prices were fake. PPC Land's report on the 21-page order explains that Judge Stephen V. Wilson of the Central District of California denied all three of Brooks Brothers' motions: to compel arbitration, to dismiss, and to strike the class allegations. The case is Martin v. BB OpCo, LLC. The proposed class covers California shoppers who bought at a purported discount on the retailer's website from March 19, 2022 onward.

Nothing in the order says Brooks Brothers misled anyone. At this stage a court accepts the complaint's facts as true and only asks whether the claim is plausible. The judge also warned that certifying a class "might be particularly challenging". The ruling still matters, because it shows which parts of an ordinary store page a court now reads as evidence.

The polo, the clearance label and the three-month rule

The whole case rests on one purchase. On January 10, 2025, the shopper bought a polo for $39.99, shown beside a struck-through $89.50 under a small "Clearance" label. That is about 55% off on the face of it. He alleges the shirt had not sold at $89.50 in the three months before, and he used archived snapshots of the website to support the timing.

California's rule is specific. Business and Professions Code section 17501 says no price may be advertised as a former price unless it was the prevailing market price within the three months before the ad, or unless the date it did prevail is "clearly, exactly and conspicuously stated". Brooks Brothers argued that the word "Clearance" told shoppers the higher price was old. The judge disagreed: a category label is not a date.

Why the terms links failed

The arbitration half of the ruling may reach more stores than the pricing half. The store argued the shopper agreed to arbitration through two kinds of links. The footer "Terms of Use" link was dark navy on off-white, not underlined, grouped with six other links, and visible only after scrolling. The court found it buried for five reasons, including small type next to larger banners and discount alerts.

The checkout links failed differently. They sat at the end of the text beside the optional email and text message sign-up boxes, so the court read them as terms for marketing messages, not for buying the shirt. A guest checkout with no account and no app looked to the judge like a one-off sale, not an ongoing relationship. The order turned font size, link color and distance from the checkout button into evidence.

What the ruling means for a New York store

The California order does not bind a New York court, but New York gives a shopper with the same complaint its own route and its own damages. Two other New York events landed in the same fortnight. On October 19, 2026, the National Retail Federation asked the Second Circuit to revive its challenge to New York's personalized pricing disclosure law, Bloomberg Law reported. On October 15, 2026, the New York Attorney General settled with Dollar General for $1.875 million over prices at the register that did not match advertised prices. The message is consistent: in New York, the price you show is a promise.

The pain points: where a strike-through price costs a store money

A fake or stale reference price hurts a store in at least six specific ways, and most of them show up as margin or legal cost rather than as a visible error. Each one below names the symptom and the fix.

1. Your compare-at field has no memory

The compare-at or "was" price on a Shopify product is a typed number, not a record. If a merchandiser set it at launch two years ago, it still shows today, even if the product has sold at the sale price ever since. You cannot answer "when did this sell at the higher price" from the product page. Fix: export every product with a compare-at value and attach a last-sold-at-that-price date to each one before November 20.

2. One New York shopper is worth at least $500 to a plaintiff

New York's false advertising statute puts a floor under every claim. Under General Business Law section 350-e, an injured person can recover actual damages or $500, whichever is greater, and up to three times actual damages capped at $10,000 if the violation was willful, plus attorney's fees. The broader deceptive practices section, 349, sets the floor at $50 with trebling up to $1,000. Multiply those floors by a holiday order count from Brooklyn, Buffalo and the rest of the state, and a crossed-out price becomes a liability line.

3. Personalized discounts may need a warning label in New York

If your store shows different prices or discounts to different New York shoppers based on their data, New York may require a disclosure next to the price. General Business Law section 349-a requires the words "THIS PRICE WAS SET BY AN ALGORITHM USING YOUR PERSONAL DATA" when an algorithm sets the price using personal data about that shopper. The Attorney General must first send a cease and desist letter, and a court can then impose up to $1,000 per violation. Fix: list every app that changes price or discount by visitor before you switch on holiday personalization.

4. The feed repeats whatever the product page says

Your shopping feed, your email platform and your paid social catalog usually pull the sale price and the former price from the same product data. PPC Land's analysis notes that a strike-through figure on a product page often appears in other channels too. One wrong compare-at value becomes a wrong ad, a wrong email and a wrong catalog card. Fix: correct the source field once, then confirm the feed refreshed before the Black Friday ads go live.

5. Your arbitration clause may not be a contract

Many stores assume their terms page protects them from class actions. Under the Brooks Brothers reasoning, a footer link plus a guest checkout may bind nobody. If your only terms link at checkout sits after the newsletter opt-in text, a court may read it as covering emails, not the order. The fix is a clear sentence beside the button that completes the purchase, saying that placing the order means accepting the linked terms.

6. Shoppers now check price history on their own

Marketplaces have started showing the history that your product page hides. From April 23, 2026, Amazon required a seller's List Price to be backed by recent sales, and from May 18 it tied its Typical Price to a 90-day median of non-promotional prices. In May, Amazon began showing a full year of price history to shoppers through its Rufus assistant. A shopper who sees a bigger "discount" on your store than the marketplace shows will distrust both.

The one-line test: for every crossed-out price on your store, can you show a date in the last 90 days when that product actually sold at that price? If the answer is no for more than a handful of products, fix the data before you build a single Black Friday ad.

By market: how New York, California and Texas treat a crossed-out price

The three states reach the same question by different roads. California writes a three-month clock into its statute. Texas lists false price reduction claims by name in its consumer protection law. New York relies on broad deceptive practices and false advertising sections that set a cash floor for every injured shopper. The table sets them side by side.

New York: statutory damages, a disclosure rule and an active Attorney General

New York's General Business Law sections 349 and 350 do not set a look-back period the way California does. They ask whether a practice is deceptive, and they reward the shopper who proves it. Section 349(h) gives any injured person actual damages or $50, whichever is greater, up to $1,000 with trebling for willful conduct, and lets the court award attorney's fees. Section 350-e raises the floor to $500 for false advertising. For a store in New York City selling mostly to local buyers, those floors make even a low-ticket item worth suing over in a group.

The Attorney General is watching price accuracy closely. The October 15, 2026 Dollar General settlement followed consumer complaints and a secret shopper visit to 11 stores in Western New York, where investigators were overcharged on about 14% of items. The office also reviewed more than 900 Weights and Measures reports and found 43% documented price accuracy failures above 2% between 2021 and 2023. That case was about physical shelves, but the Attorney General's stated principle is simple: a shopper who sees a sale price should be charged that price. An online store whose ad shows one price and whose cart shows another is the digital version of the same complaint.

The personalized pricing rule is the newest layer. The Second Circuit heard the retail trade group's appeal on October 19, 2026, after Judge Jed Rakoff dismissed its First Amendment challenge in October 2025. Until a court says otherwise, the disclosure duty stands. For more on how we approach the New York market, see our New York page.

StateRule on former pricesWhat a shopper or the state can recoverExtra rule to watch in 2026
New YorkGeneral deceptive practices (GBL 349) and false advertising (GBL 350); no fixed look-back period$50 floor under 349, $500 floor under 350-e, trebled up to $1,000 or $10,000 if willful, plus attorney's feesGBL 349-a disclosure for personalized algorithmic prices, $1,000 per violation after a cease and desist letter
CaliforniaBus. and Prof. Code 17501: prevailing market price within the past three months, or a clearly stated dateClass claims under the False Advertising Law, Consumers Legal Remedies Act and Unfair Competition LawTerms links buried in the footer or tied to email opt-ins may not create an arbitration agreement
TexasDTPA 17.46(b)(11): false or misleading statements about the reasons for, existence of, or amount of price reductionsUp to $10,000 per violation in a state action, plus up to $250,000 more where shoppers aged 65 or older were targetedThe Consumer Protection Division can seek an injunction and restitution for identifiable shoppers

California and Texas: a clock and a named offense

California has produced a steady run of strike-through suits, because section 17501 gives plaintiffs a clear test. A store selling into Los Angeles or San Diego needs either three months of sales at the former price or a plainly stated date. The Brooks Brothers order adds that a "Clearance" or "Sale" label does not count as that date. PPC Land lists earlier California cases against Pillow Cube, over a $134.99 price shown against $179.99, and Patagonia, where the complaint said products ran continuous sale prices for 98 days. Shipping to California puts you inside that pattern.

Texas names the problem directly. The Deceptive Trade Practices Act, section 17.46(b)(11), lists false or misleading statements about the reasons for, existence of, or amount of price reductions as a deceptive act. In a state action, section 17.47(c) allows a civil penalty of up to $10,000 per violation, and up to $250,000 more where the practice was aimed at consumers aged 65 or older. A Texas store selling to Houston and Dallas buyers during the holiday rush should treat an inflated "was" price as a named offense, not a gray area.

Hidden costs: where your crossed-out prices come from

Most stale reference prices are not a decision anyone made. They are leftovers from launches, imports and promotions that nobody cleaned up.

Imports, bulk edits and supplier list prices

When products are imported from a supplier file or a migration, the supplier's list price often lands in the compare-at field by default. That number was never your selling price. If your catalog came over from another platform, assume some compare-at values are supplier list prices until you prove otherwise. The FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing describe a legitimate former price as one at which the item was openly and actively offered for sale for a reasonably substantial period, in the recent, regular course of business, in good faith. A supplier's suggested price on day one does not meet that description.

Permanent sales that became the regular price

A product that has been "on sale" for months is, in practice, selling at its regular price. The FTC guides give the example of a seller who raises a price briefly only to advertise a cut back to the usual level, and call that bargain false. A store that runs a sitewide discount all autumn and then adds a Black Friday code on top may be showing two layers of reference price, neither of which shoppers ever paid. The fix is to reset the compare-at field when a sale price has run long enough to become the real price.

Apps that rewrite prices on the fly

Discount apps, bundle apps, upsell widgets and personalization tools can show a crossed-out price that does not exist in your product data at all. In New York, any of them that set a price using data about the individual shopper may also trigger the section 349-a disclosure. List every app that touches price display, note whether it uses visitor data, and test each one from a fresh browser before the sale starts.

Do not delete every strike-through price in a panic. Honest comparisons convert, and removing them all throws away real value. The goal is a crossed-out price you can document, shown with a clear basis such as "Our price from August 1 to October 31", not no comparison at all.

What works: discounts you can prove, terms shoppers actually see

The approach that holds up is simple: show a former price only when your own sales data backs it, say what the comparison is, and put your terms where a shopper agrees to them.

Tie every reference price to a date

California's statute already offers the cleanest safe harbor: state when the former price prevailed. A line such as "Was $89.50 from June 1 to August 31, 2026" answers the question a court asked in the Brooks Brothers case. Build a simple rule into your catalog process: no compare-at value without a date range and a sales record behind it, and an automatic reset once that range is older than 90 days.

Put the terms sentence next to the Place Order button

The Ninth Circuit test the court applied asks for conspicuous notice and a clear action that shows agreement. In practice that means one plain sentence directly above or beside the button that completes the order, saying that placing the order means accepting the linked terms, in readable type and an obvious link color. Keep it separate from the newsletter and text message boxes, so nobody can read it as covering marketing only.

Let your ads and emails read from one checked source

Fix the product data once and let every channel inherit the fix. Before Black Friday creative is approved, run your feed through a check that flags any product whose compare-at price has no supporting sale in the last 90 days. Pull those products from "save X%" messaging and promote them on product benefits instead. Adobe projects Cyber Monday online sales of $15.1 billion and Black Friday of $12.9 billion in 2026, so the days you most need clean data are the days you can least afford a pulled ad.

Decide on personalization before New York decides for you

If personalized discounts do not move your numbers much, turning them off for New York shoppers is the simplest path. If they do, add the exact disclosure wording the statute requires next to the personalized price and keep a record of when it went live. Running it in New York with no disclosure and no record is the one choice you cannot defend.

How Leadnox helps online stores price with confidence

Leadnox works with online stores to clean up the product data, page design and ad feeds that carry their prices, so holiday discounts convert without creating evidence for a lawsuit. We are not your lawyers, and we say when a question needs one. What we do is find the numbers on your site that nobody can back up, and rebuild the pages and campaigns around numbers you can.

A reference price audit across store, feed and email

We export every product with a compare-at value, match it against your order history, and sort the catalog into three groups: documented, needs a date, and needs a reset. We then trace those same products through your shopping feed, email templates and paid social catalog, so the fix lands everywhere at once.

Checkout and terms placement that holds up and converts

We redesign the final checkout step so the terms sentence sits beside the order button in readable type, separate from marketing opt-ins, and we test the change so it does not cost you completed orders. For stores selling into New York, we also map every app that changes prices by visitor and set up the disclosure where it applies. You can see how we work with stores like yours on our e-commerce page.

Measuring: how to know your pricing is clean and still selling

Four numbers tell you whether your discounts are both honest and effective. Track them weekly through December.

Share of compare-at prices with a documented sale

Divide the number of products whose crossed-out price has a sale at that price in the last 90 days by the number of products showing any crossed-out price. Good looks like 100% before Black Friday. Anything below 90% means stale prices are still live somewhere in the catalog.

Conversion rate on dated versus undated discounts

Compare conversion on products that show a dated comparison with those that show a plain strike-through. Measure on your own traffic whether adding a date lowers conversion. If the dated version converts within a few tenths of a point of the old one, you have removed the risk at almost no cost.

Feed mismatches flagged before launch

Count products where the price in your shopping feed, email or catalog differs from the price on the product page. Good looks like zero on the morning of November 27.

Price complaints and chargebacks by state

Tag customer service tickets that mention a price that "was not really a discount" or "did not match the ad", and split them by shipping state. A rise in New York, California or Texas tickets during Cyber 5 is your earliest warning that a reference price slipped through.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. New York's General Business Law sections 349 and 350 cover deceptive pricing, and an injured shopper can recover actual damages or a statutory floor of $50 under section 349 or $500 under section 350-e, with trebling for willful violations and attorney's fees. A group of New York shoppers can bring those claims together, so a stale crossed-out price across many orders can add up quickly.

On October 22, 2026, a federal judge in California refused to dismiss a suit over a $39.99 polo shown against a struck-through $89.50, and refused to send it to arbitration. The judge found the "Clearance" label did not state when the higher price applied, and that footer and email opt-in terms links did not bind the shopper. The order made no finding that the price was actually misleading.

California sets the clearest rule: the former price must have been the prevailing market price within the three months before the ad, or the ad must clearly state the date it applied. The FTC's guides ask for a price openly offered for a reasonably substantial period in the recent, regular course of business. Keeping a dated sales record for every crossed-out price within the last 90 days meets both tests.

Possibly not. In the Brooks Brothers ruling, a terms link in the footer and links beside email and text opt-ins were found too buried to create an arbitration agreement for a guest purchase. Courts applying that test look for a clear notice tied to an action the shopper must take. A plain sentence beside the order button, saying that ordering means accepting the terms, is far stronger.

Yes. The Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act names false statements about the existence or amount of price reductions as a deceptive act, and the state can seek up to $10,000 per violation. California's section 17501 bars former prices that did not prevail within three months unless a date is stated, and shoppers there bring class claims under the state's false advertising and unfair competition laws.

Can you prove every crossed-out price on your store?

Leadnox audits reference prices, checkout terms and shopping feeds for online stores in New York, California and Texas, so your Black Friday discounts convert on numbers you can document. Start with a free pricing and checkout audit.

Get My Free Pricing Audit